After scoring for a second time with the Port Washington Black-legged Kittiwake, I decided to try my luck at Pugh Marina in Racine County WI. It was a wise decision. Let me start by saying the viewing conditions at this location are for the most part above average. Just like many other sites that harbor good numbers of wintering gulls, the lake should be iced-in and the birds will congregrate close to shore. About two-thirds of the gulls were within 100 yards and the rest were nestled on the break-wall about 300 yards away.
Immediately after getting out of my car I spotted a 1st cycle Iceland Gull (L.g. kumlieni) with the naked eye. Wisconsin birder Rick Fare was already watching the gulls when I arrived. I got him on the ICGU and what came out of my mouth next was completely unexpected. I said, "I think I have a Glaucous-winged Gull". I also apologized for showing up and abruptly calling a bird like GWGU within my first two minutes of arriving. We watched the bird for a few minutes and both of us agreed it was the size of an American Herring Gull or even bigger.
The bird is seemingly "okay" at first glance for a Glaucous-winged Gull but there are some particulars that become troubling after taking a close look. First, the bill is not much different than the AMHE to its left. That is, the bill is not massive and it lacks any noticable angle to the gonys. Yes, this may be overlooked in females and younger birds and although the bird does carry that bottom-heavy look of a Glaucous-winged, the wing pattern is not right for a pure GWGU. Here is a shot of the spread wing.
Notice the Herring-like window on the inner-primaries. Pure GWGUs should have an even, concolorous look throughout the entire primary panel, extending through to the secondaries as well. The contrast among the outter-primaries and the inner-primaries is a bit too strong.
While resting, the bird clearly shows wingtips that are darker than the tertials and the rest of the body -- another minus for pure Glaucous-winged!
What I have learned, first-hand, is that this hybrid combination can be mistook for an "oversized" Thayer's Gull. This is mainly due to the the "venetian blind" effect on the outter primaries on the spread wing. One thing to note is that the inner-webs on the outter-primaries are a bit paler on Thayer's. The contrast between the inner-webs and outter-webs should be more exaggerated for a Thayer's Gull. Also, it would be very hard to make the case for Thayer's seeing that this bird's body size matched/exceeded all of the American Herrings around it. Although there is overlap between female Herrings and male Thayer's, there weren't any gulls on the ice that this individual was smaller than.
2nd cycle Thayer's above. The presumed 2nd cycle GWGU X American Herring below.
Both birds were photographed in Feb. 2010 along Lake Michigan.